| Date | Location | Result | |
| 04/11/2009 | Stevenson, MD | Stevenson University 3, New Jersey City U. 2 (31-29,27-30,30-22,27-30,15-12) | Box score |
| 04/08/2009 | Mahwah, NJ | Ramapo College 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-23,30-20,30-23) | Box score |
| 03/23/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | Stevens 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-24,30-25,30-21) | Box score |
| 03/21/2009 | Lancaster, PA | New Jersey City U. 3, Lancaster Bible 1 (30-21,30-25,23-30,30-21) | Box score |
| 03/21/2009 | Lancaster, PA | New Jersey City U. 3, SUNY IT 1 (30-20,33-31,24-30,30-19) | Box score |
| 03/19/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | SUNY New Paltz 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-17,30-25,30-27) | Box score |
| 03/14/2009 | Jamaica, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, SUNY IT 1 (30-25,30-24,16-30,30-25) | Box score |
| 03/14/2009 | Jamaica, NY | Quincy University 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-22,30-12,30-25) | Box score |
| 03/13/2009 | Jamaica, NY | King College (TN) 3, New Jersey City U. 1 (30-27,30-26,28-30,30-20) | Box score |
| 03/13/2009 | Jamaica, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Stevenson University 2 (0-30,30-27,30-32,30-27,18-16) | Box score |
| 03/11/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | Ramapo College 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-24,30-13,30-23) | Box score |
| 03/10/2009 | Annandale-Hudson, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Bard College 2 (30-24,23-30,27-30,30-18,15-11) | Box score |
| 03/08/2009 | New York, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Yeshiva University 0 (30-13,30-19,30-22) | Box score |
| 03/07/2009 | Poughkeepsie, NY | Vassar College 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-19,30-18,30-23) | Box score |
| 03/06/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, Lancaster Bible 1 (30-26,30-20,29-31,30-16) | Box score |
| 03/05/2009 | New York, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Hunter College 2 (25-30,27-30,30-21,34-32,15-12) | Box score |
| 02/26/2009 | New Paltz, NY | SUNY New Paltz 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-26,30-22,30-24) | Box score |
| 02/21/2009 | Stevenson, MD | Stevenson University 3, New Jersey City U. 1 (25-30,30-20,30-23,30-25) | Box score |
| 02/21/2009 | Stevenson, MD | New Jersey City U. 3, Hilbert College 2 (30-25,22-30,26-30,30-22,15-7) | Box score |
| 02/17/2009 | Brooklyn, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Brooklyn College 1 (26-30,30-24,30-18,30-22) | Box score |
| 02/15/2009 | Beverly, MA | MIT 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-20,30-19,30-18) | Box score |
| 02/15/2009 | Beverly, MA | Rivier College 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-24,30-21,30-20) | Box score |
| 02/14/2009 | Beverly, MA | New Jersey City U. 3, Emmanuel College 2 (30-27,27-30,30-25,28-30,15-12) | Box score |
| 02/14/2009 | Beverly, MA | Endicott College 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-28,30-17,30-13) | Box score |
| 02/11/2009 | Brooklyn, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Polytechnic U. 0 (30-20,30-24,30-16) | Box score |
| 02/09/2009 | Dobbs Ferry, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Mount Saint Vincent 1 (30-27,30-21,24-30,30-20) | Box score |
| 02/07/2009 | Jersey City,NJ | SUNY New Paltz 3, New Jersey City U. 1 (30-23,28-30,30-27,30-13) | Box score |
| 02/07/2009 | Jersey City,NJ | Stevenson University 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-28,30-25,30-25) | Box score |
| 02/07/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, Wentworth 0 (30-25,30-26,30-27) | Box score |
| 02/05/2009 | Purchase, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, SUNY Purchase 0 (30-23,30-25,30-21) | Box score |
| 02/04/2009 | Jamaica, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, York College (NY) 0 (30-22,30-19,30-25) | Box score |
| 02/01/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, Medgar Evers College 0 (30-8,30-10,30-8) | Box score |
| 01/30/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, City College of NY 0 (30-16,30-19,30-25) | Box score |
| 01/29/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, Brooklyn College 0 (30-16,30-14,30-15) | Box score |
| 01/27/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | Baruch College 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (30-16,30-28,30-28) | Box score |
| 01/22/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, Lehman College 0 (30-19,30-15,30-21) | Box score |