| Date | Location | Result | |
| 10/29/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, John Jay College 1 (25-17,26-28,25-12,26-24) | Box score |
| 10/22/2009 | Bronx, NY | New Jersey City U. 3, Lehman College 1 (25-16,25-13,21-25,25-23) | Box score |
| 10/20/2009 | Camden, NJ | Rutgers-Camden 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-21,28-26,25-19) | Box score |
| 10/17/2009 | Hoboken, NJ | Stevens 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-12,25-16,25-20) | Box score |
| 10/15/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | Rowan University 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-18,25-15,25-21) | Box score |
| 10/13/2009 | Mahwah, NJ | Ramapo College of NJ 3, New Jersey City U. 2 (25-13,23-25,25-20,16-25,15-9) | Box score |
| 10/10/2009 | Stevenson, MD | Stevenson University 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-10,25-22,25-19) | Box score |
| 10/10/2009 | Stevenson, MD | Lancaster Bible Coll 3, New Jersey City U. 1 (23-25,28-26,25-17,25-22) | Box score |
| 10/06/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | Richard Stockton 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-14,25-14,25-10) | Box score |
| 10/03/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | Baruch College 3, New Jersey City U. 1 (25-16,23-25,25-18,25-11) | Box score |
| 10/02/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, York College (NY) 0 (25-8,25-17,25-6) | Box score |
| 09/29/2009 | Union, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, Kean University 2 (25-15,19-25,25-21,19-25,15-13) | Box score |
| 09/24/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | Montclair State U. 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-12,25-21,25-18) | Box score |
| 09/22/2009 | Wayne, NJ | William Paterson 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-23,25-8,25-10) | Box score |
| 09/19/2009 | New Paltz, NY | Johnson & Wales U. 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-18,25-8,25-18) | Box score |
| 09/19/2009 | New Paltz, NY | Mount St. Mary (NY) 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-19,25-19,25-22) | Box score |
| 09/18/2009 | New Paltz, NY | Johns Hopkins U. 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-10,25-9,25-19) | Box score |
| 09/18/2009 | New Paltz, NY | SUNY-New Paltz 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-7,25-8,25-9) | Box score |
| 09/15/2009 | Jersey City, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, Rutgers-Newark 0 (25-7,25-20,25-10) | Box score |
| 09/12/2009 | Mahwah, NJ | St. Joseph's (NY) 3, New Jersey City U. 1 (25-12,26-28,25-19,25-17) | Box score |
| 09/12/2009 | Mahwah, NJ | New Jersey City U. 3, SUNY-Purchase 0 (25-14,25-17,25-21) | Box score |
| 09/05/2009 | Langhorne, PA | New Jersey City U. 3, Farmingdale State 1 (21-25,25-19,25-18,25-13) | Box score |
| 09/05/2009 | Langhorne, PA | Phila. Biblical U. 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-16,25-14,25-22) | Box score |
| 09/05/2009 | Langhorne, PA | Baruch College 3, New Jersey City U. 0 (25-22,25-19,26-24) | Box score |